When Bankruptcy Becomes a Weapon: The Catholic Church’s Long Game Against Survivors

Forty-four Catholic dioceses and religious orders across the country have sought bankruptcy protection since clergy sexual abuse claims began forcing the issue two decades ago. Two of them are in Louisiana, and a third may be next.

The Archdiocese of New Orleans filed for Chapter 11 in May 2020. The Diocese of Alexandria followed on Oct. 31, 2025, becoming the 41st U.S. diocese to take that route. Now the Diocese of Lafayette, already facing dozens of clergy abuse lawsuits, has enrolled a bankruptcy attorney in one of its pending cases, a move that often precedes a filing of its own. Whether or not Lafayette ultimately files, the pattern across the state is unmistakable: when survivors gain ground in court, dioceses reach for bankruptcy.

It is worth being precise about what that means for survivors. A Chapter 11 filing does not simply reorganize a diocese’s finances. It freezes every pending lawsuit against it. Discovery stops. Depositions stop. Trial dates disappear. Survivors who have waited years, sometimes decades, for a jury of their peers to hear their case are instead folded into a claims process with payouts set by formula rather than verdict.

The Archdiocese of New Orleans shows how long that process can take, even after a settlement is reached. More than five years passed between its May 2020 bankruptcy filing and a federal judge’s Dec. 8, 2025approval of a $230 million settlement for roughly 600 survivors. Even then, survivors were not paid on the spot. The Archdiocese’s own attorneys said it would take until the end of December just to get the money into a settlement trust, with individual payments to survivors following in early 2026, nearly six years after the case began. Five years is not a rounding error. It is half a decade in which survivors, many already in their sixties and seventies, waited for resolution while the institution that harmed them kept operating, kept raising money, and kept litigating.

Continue reading at The Current

Share