The United States Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB) never misses a chance to flex its moral megaphone when the victim fits the world’s narrative. Four days after George Floyd’s death, Archbishop José Gomez had a polished statement on racism, police brutality, and reconciliation ready to go, stamped with the full authority of the bishops’ conference. The talking points landed right in line with CNN. The institutional Church bent over backward to show it “got it.”
Fast forward to 2025. Charlie Kirk is gunned down on stage in front of thousands of college students; a political assassination of a Christian public figure. Four days pass. And from the USCCB? Nothing. Not a single collective statement, not even a boilerplate “we pray for the repose of his soul and the comfort of his family.” Silence.
Individual bishops spoke, Burbidge in Arlington, Solis in Salt Lake City, a few others with pious platitudes, but the conference as a body, the same one that can churn out press releases on climate change and immigration at the drop of a hat, suddenly found itself tongue-tied. The “prophetic voice” of the Church in America could not muster the courage to say a murdered evangelical deserved prayer.
Why? Because Kirk is the wrong kind of victim. Floyd’s death advanced a preferred narrative; Kirk’s death exposes the rot of political hatred and leftist violence. One is useful, the other inconvenient. And so the shepherds stay silent.
It’s not just cowardice, it’s catechesis by omission. The bishops are teaching Catholics that some lives deserve liturgical lament and Vatican tears, while others are better left unmentioned lest the wrong people get offended. In 2020, the Church offered Our Lady of Guadalupe to America for George Floyd. In 2025, it offered diplomatic whispers for Charlie Kirk.
Silence is not neutral. It’s a decision, and in this case, a disgraceful one.
Continue reading at Hiraeth In Exile
TAKE ACTION: Contact USCCB President Archbishop Timothy Broglio at tpbroglio@milarch.org or 202-719-3600 and let him know what you think.