Considerations on the Cardinal’s Considerations

The Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith has produced Venite ad me, subtitled “Considerations on the Transmission of the Faith in an Epochal Change.” The document is supposedly the response of the Dicastery to appeals by both Pope Francis and Pope Leo confronting the decline of the Catholic Faith, especially in countries traditionally “Catholic.”

There are some strange notes in the document, which is the usual anthology of quotations from papal discourses and encyclicals. “One final clarification concerns the document’s genre: it is a set of Considerations, not a Doctrinal Note.” Its purpose is to “stimulate ecclesial reflection.” “A variety of points of view” are examined, “without, however, claiming to settle the matter.” Unlike other documents coming from the Dicastery, the “Considerations are not marked by…terminological precision and systematic treatment.”

It is as if the umpire chose to give tips about batting without getting too “technical.” His job is to get technical. The Dicastery is supposed to be a referee, not a player in the game. The deliberate exclusion of terminological precision and systematic treatment is strange.

I was reminded of what G. K. Chesterton wrote in Orthodoxy about criticisms of doctrinal specificity:

Here it is enough to notice that if some small mistake were made in doctrine, huge blunders might be made in human happiness. A sentence phrased wrong about the nature of symbolism would have broken all the best statues in Europe. A slip in the definitions might stop all the dances; might wither all the Christmas trees or break all the Easter eggs. Doctrines had to be defined within strict limits, even in order that man might enjoy general human liberties. The Church had to be careful, if only that the world might be careless. This is the thrilling romance of Orthodoxy.

The Dicastery is supposed to be a referee, not a player in the game.

Continue reading at Crisis Magazine

Share