Catholics Considering Not Voting: Read This First

There is something almost magnificent about a political philosophy that manages to transform doing nothing into a demonstration of superior moral seriousness.

A man studies the errors of liberalism. He discovers that the American constitutional order does not acknowledge the Social Kingship of Christ. He examines the available candidates, finds their religious and political convictions deficient, and announces that he will have nothing to do with the whole wretched business.

He has preserved his principles. He has kept his hands clean. He has achieved the satisfaction of being able to explain, at considerable length, why everyone participating in the election has compromised with modernity.

And if the eventual government adopts policies injurious to religious institutions, parents, unborn children, or the exercise of conscience, well, the inhabitants of the modern liberal state will simply have to endure the consequences.

Presumably, they should find some consolation in knowing that our man never compromised.

That is the problem at the heart of the emerging politics of electoral abstention being promoted by Alexander Petersen of American Reform, Anthony Abbate of Avoiding Babylon, and Stephen Kokx of Integrity Magazine.

Their argument concerns the moral worthiness of candidates, the legitimacy of political compromise, and the obligation of Catholics to participate in elections conducted under a fundamentally non-Catholic political order.

Those are serious questions. The traditional Catholic moral theologians treated them seriously.

But the contemporary debate has acquired a peculiar atmosphere of self-congratulation, as though identifying the philosophical defects of American government constitutes a sufficient discharge of one’s duties toward the people governed by it.

It does not.

Continue reading at Hiraeth in Exile

Share