A couple of weeks ago, leftist theologian Rich Raho posted on 𝕏 celebrating the advancement of Dorothy Day’s cause for canonization, linking to an article by Michael Fox at Catholics for the Common Good. Upon seeing his post, I reposted his statement and wrote one of my own: “There is only one reason her cause for sainthood is being pushed.” When asked to clarify what that reason was, I answered in four words: “The canonization of socialism.”
I stand by that.
The pushback was immediate; even normally conservative Catholics took issue with my statement. Cries that “she wasn’t a socialist, she renounced her communism,” and “she was for decentralization,” and even the completely unsubstantiated claim that “she called the state the greatest enemy of the church today,” reverberated first on 𝕏 and then in private emails. But here’s the problem: I didn’t call her a socialist. What I said was that her cause was being pushed as a means of canonizing socialism. These are two very different and very distinct things.
In truth, Dorothy Day was a very complex and controversial figure with a long history of denouncing Communism while praising its thinkers, leaders, and revolutionists—and the majority of those longing to see her canonized lean ideologically toward a socialist worldview. We’ve seen this dance before. The elevation of Pope John XXIII and Pope Paul VI was pressed, in no small part, as a way to lock the Second Vatican Council into the Church’s official memory as an unquestionable good. To raise a man to the altars is to raise his project with him.
Continue reading at Crisis Magazine
