When Catholic leaders from across Europe met in mid-September to discuss “Shaping Synodality in Europe,” a consensus quickly emerged that the church’s new guiding principle was here to stay.
But there were questions about how synodality can best be applied — in a continent of differing societies, cultures, languages and histories.
“This meeting was extremely important in bringing all of Europe together,” said Myriam Wijlens, a Dutch canon law professor at the German University of Erfurt and a consultor to the Synod of Bishops’ general secretariat in Rome.
“It confirms a real dialogue is underway, particularly between Catholics in Eastern and Western Europe, who are now gaining trust by encountering each other’s pains and anxieties. This deepening in mutual understanding needs to continue,” she told NCR.
The symposium, held Sept. 14-17 at the Puchberg Castle in Wels, Austria, and hosted by Catholic Private University of Linz, Austria, was attended by representatives of 29 bishops’ conferences. Organizers described it as marking a milestone in implementing the synodal process started by Pope Francis. It produced the workings of a European “roadmap” for the next synodal assembly in Rome in 2028, addressing the continent’s “wounds and challenges,” while also focusing on empowerment and transformation.
“As a church, we too often give answers to questions no one has asked — we are being called out of our self-preoccupation and back into the reality of people’s lives,” explained pastoral theologian Klara-Antonia Csiszar, the Austrian convener. “Europe isn’t only a geographical space. It’s a space of condensed experience, of war and fear, violence and flight, polarization and exhaustion, loss of trust, loneliness, abuse and religious estrangement. But Europe is also a space of great longing — for peace, community, dignity, justice and hope,” Csiszar said.
Continue reading at National Catholic Reporter
A conservative critique of Myriam Wijlens (via Grok)
The objection is not that she is unqualified. It is that her project treats the Church’s sacramental constitution as a structure that canon law may redesign once a consultation has spoken.
- Synodality as a substitute for hierarchy. Wijlens describes a synodal Church as one that listens and then renders an account, and she has said Francis “pressed the reset button.” In interviews she presents her task as hearing what people say and working out what that means theologically and canonically, while insisting she does not herself decide. That division of labor is the problem. Catholic ecclesiology does not derive doctrine or the power of governance from the aggregated desires of the baptized. Lumen Gentium distinguishes the common priesthood of the faithful from the ministerial priesthood, which differs “in essence and not only in degree.” A process that begins with open consultation and ends with a mandate to rewrite the canons inverts that order: the sensus fidelium is no longer a witness to what the Church already believes, but a source the law must catch up with.
- Governance detached from orders. Her published work argues for a “paradigm shift” in which ministry is considered inside ecclesiology rather than ecclesiology being built on ministry, and for lay participation in leadership and governance. The 2026 commission report follows that line, including the possibility that lay people serve as judges in cases that can end in dismissal from the clerical state or excommunication, and a wider opening of pastoral councils, even to Christians not in full communion. Traditional canon law ties the power of governance to holy orders (canon 129). Expanding lay jurisdiction in penal matters does not merely “implement baptismal dignity.” It relocates acts that touch the clerical state into hands that do not possess the sacrament those acts concern. Accountability for bishops who ignored warnings before ordination — a point she has rightly stressed from her investigative work — can be secured by enforcing existing penal law. It does not require lay judges over priests.
- Women’s ministry left artificially open. She has repeatedly said that the request for women in decision-making and in the diaconate comes from “the whole community,” and that the synod, not she, must discern it. That is a studied agnosticism. Ordinatio Sacerdotalis already settled the question of priestly ordination. In December 2025 the second Petrocchi commission, reporting to Leo XIV, judged that Scripture, Tradition, and the magisterium rule out admitting women to the diaconate understood as a grade of holy orders, while leaving a fully definitive formulation for later. Treating the diaconate as an unfinished listening item keeps a settled sacramental question inside a political process.
- Ecumenism that softens Catholic markers. A habilitation on Eucharistic sharing, long service in Faith and Order, and advocacy of receptive ecumenism sit comfortably with a Church that negotiates its differences. Conservative Catholic ecumenism seeks the return of separated brethren to the faith whole and entire. Structures that invite members of other communions onto diocesan pastoral councils, or that treat intercommunion as a canonical problem to be managed, blur the meaning of full communion rather than serve it.
- The abuse crisis used as a lever. Her record on penal investigations and child-protection norms is the strongest part of her work, and the demand that superiors who ignored pre-ordination warnings be held to account is just. The critique is the use to which that record is put. She presents abuse cases as proof that the synodal path is already underway, and she folds accountability into a general reform of participation, women’s roles, and church structures. Protection of minors is a duty under the existing law and moral theology. It is not evidence that the Church must become a co-responsible assembly whose law follows the consultation.
In short: Wijlens is a capable canonist who has used real failures of bishops and superiors to argue for a different Church — one in which baptismal equality, synodal process, and revised canons steadily displace the distinction between clergy and laity. A conservative reading holds that those failures call for penitence and enforcement, not a reset.
