The result of this process is a Church that no longer liberates the world, but allows itself to be judged by it, to the point of renouncing its own mission.
The crisis facing the Church cannot be reduced to a superficial clash between supposed “conservatives” and “progressives.” The underlying conflict is deeper and more decisive: a confrontation between Reality and Utopia, between Christian realism and ideology. This is what theologian Msgr. Nicola Bux and essayist Vito Palmiotti argue in a recent dialogue organized by La Nuova Bussola Quotidiana, dedicated precisely to this central axis of contemporary ecclesial debate.
The conversation, led by Stefano Chiappalone as part of the Venerdì della Bussola, revolved around the book Realtà e Utopia nella Chiesa, published by the same Italian outlet and which also includes a previously unpublished epistolary exchange between Msgr. Nicola Bux and Emeritus Pope Benedict XVI.
According to the authors, the use of categories borrowed from political language has contributed to hiding the real problem. It is not a dispute of sensitivities, but a progressive disconnection from Christian reality, which has a proper name: Jesus Christ.
Bux expresses it clearly: ideology has displaced reality to the point that Christ has become the great absentee from Christianity. People speak of peace, justice, fraternity, or welcome, but avoid naming their source. “Reality belongs to Christ,” the theologian reminds us, quoting the Letter to the Colossians, and yet that elementary fact has been relegated by increasingly abstract and humanitarian ecclesial discourse.
For decades— he warns— emphasis has been placed on “values” detached from their supernatural root, trusting that they would suffice on their own. The result has been the opposite: values without Christ turn into utopias, incapable of taking root in the real life of the faithful.
Continue reading at Infovaticana
