Prevost Was Bergoglio’s Only Candidate

“Your Eminence, how did it go? Is it true that Parolin withdrew his candidacy? Is it true that the College of Cardinals wanted to find a more moderate candidate after Bergoglio?” “My dear son,” he said to me, “you just don’t understand: Prevost was Bergoglio’s only candidate. Even shortly before he died, that stubborn old Argentine called all the cardinals he could trust and told them: ‘I remind you: after me, it’s the American’s turn. A missionary, an Augustinian, he will be the best for the Universal Church.’”
“So why those votes for Parolin?” I tried to contradict him.

“On the first ballot, Prevost was already ahead of everyone, far ahead of everyone. The black smoke on the evening of May 7th arrived so late because that holy man, Monsignor Cantalamessa, had overindulged in his spiritual exercises. Prevost, as competitors, had to his left, led by the hyper-Bergoglians, those I call ‘Bergoglians despite Bergoglio and beyond Bergoglio,’ namely Parolin, and to his right, the traditionalists, led by Robert Sarah, supported by Cardinal Erdo.” “But why Prevost?” I asked.

“Because Bergoglio was very clear that after his pushback, a ‘normalizer’ was needed, someone who could reassure the Curia, even though he wasn’t a member of the Curia; someone who could reassure the progressives, even though he wasn’t a traditionalist; and finally, someone who could reassure the traditionalists, because he was seen as a moderate. This last thing was what worried the old Pope most; he had a clear sense that, at a certain point in his pontificate, schism had actually come close. In short, someone was needed to unite, even a little gray, if you like, but after the fireworks, a little silence is good. Look,” he said, bringing his face closer to mine, “I’ll confess something to you, even the name, on that too I think the Argentine pampas had their say; they needed the name of a Pope of tradition, but also the first Pope who opened the Church to the modern world, the one of ‘Rerum Novarum’.”

“Who broke the deadlock?” I asked with invasive curiosity.

“So you don’t understand! There was never an impasse! The other votes were only a few votes short. Only then, to put an end to the matter immediately, did Bergoglio’s most trusted man, Cardinal Jean-Claude Hollerich, coincidentally the general rapporteur of the Synod, Bergoglio’s brainchild, take action; Hollerich set things straight, and Parolin, at that point, declared his unwillingness to be elected. So it was a landslide: 107 votes. I believe poor Erdoğan even asked not to be voted for again, but the hardline traditionalists had figured out the game and wanted to represent their dissent. In short, only those who made a mistake didn’t vote for Prevost.” And so he burst into a loud, liberating, and therefore also a little raucous, laugh. “And your position, Your Eminence, how were you positioned?”

I’ve been on Prevost’s side since the beginning. I know him and I share Bergoglio’s logic. He’s the best choice, certainly less flashy, but we need someone who can consolidate Francis’s ‘shoulders’, we need a Paul VI who can reassure and confirm. Prevost is a worthy person, very serious, available, a missionary at heart. I have only one doubt about his physical condition—the Pope’s workload is terrible—but you’ll see, he’ll be able to organize himself around this too. Regarding John XXIII, a distinguished theologian, Hannah Arendt, wrote of him: ‘A Christian on the throne of Peter.’ I think this expression could also be applied to Francis; while for Leo one could say: ‘A priest, on the throne of Peter.’ In short, that’s what’s needed in a historical period like this.”

“Well, of course, also as a geopolitical choice.” “Exactly, think about the relationship between an American and Trump. They were all ready to cry ‘Third World scandal’ with the election of an Asian, or worse, an African. The Argentine Jesuit had thought of that too and fooled them. Bergoglio was a genius!” “Yes, but now, if I understand correctly, everything is on ice. The whole dynamic set in motion by the Bergoglian revolution has ground to a halt,” I objected.

“Quite the opposite. Bergoglio had realized he had reached the breaking point. In fact, he didn’t push any further on priestly celibacy, female priesthood, and other issues that have been the subject of doctrinal controversy for centuries. Now it’s a matter of consolidating the space he occupied, until the next pontiff, who will likely be an African and will take a further, decisive, final step forward. You’ll see that after Leo there will be a John XXIV,” he says smiling, “and then the Synod. That will be the spirit of Bergoglio that will remain in the Church to watch over Her.”

Continue reading at Rome Today
 

 

Share