This is a story about why you can never take anything for granted and assume what you see is what you are going to get. While we are all familiar with the term “caveat emptor” (buyer beware), we certainly do not think in those terms when we join a religious organization that we believe is affiliated with our church. You must always dig deeper to ensure you know everything you need to know about what you are joining. Research is necessary given all the evil entities who want to infiltrate the Catholic Church and its affiliations.
I was in discernment to become a Lay member of the Carmelites of the Ancient Observance (O. Carm.) for six years and five months. I was scheduled to be fully professed in seven months. This Mass and profession ceremony would have completed a seven-year discernment process.
A Warning! (from the Holy Spirit?)
Recently an article appeared in the Catholic Loop entitled “Tradition versus Ideology in Carmelite Formation.” The Loop article discusses an article published in Crisis Magazine entitled, “Infiltration Comes to the Lay Carmelites.”
The Crisis article discussed the discernment process in Lay Carmelite community in North Dakota, and specifically addresses issues raised in a textbook used in that process.
The book at issue, Climbing the Mountain, The Carmelite Journey Second Edition according to the author of the Crisis article emphasizes social justice, eco-theology, and progressive theology. Climbing the Mountain was edited by Johan Bergström-Allen, (an openly professed Gay man). The editor did not use a version of the Bible authorized by the Catholic Church (NAB or NRSV-CE) he used an ecumenical translation that aligns with his pro-LGBT+ agenda.
The book also does not have the Catholic Imprimatur, or a Nihil Obstat. These approvals are required in Catholic teaching as indicated in Canon Law 823.2 “. . . there shall be “. . . no ill effects on the faith and morals of Christ’s faithful.” The book also contains the following disclaimer on the copyright page: “The British Province of Carmelites does not necessarily endorse the individual views in its publication.”
These two articles spurred me into additional research particularly because I was so close to my Final Profession.
Research With Disappointing Results
My research yielded very disturbing results. Step one of my investigations was to contact the Bismarck Diocese to see what additional information was available about the process that led to their disbanding of their Carmelite community.
The concerns of the individual who authored the article were elevated to Bishop David Kagan in the Bismarck diocese and were shared with me by the Tribunal Advocate. She was an O. Carm. for twenty-five years and, coincidentally, the formation director for this community.
She has provided me her preliminary analysis that was forwarded to the bishop. In the analysis, she indicated it conflicts with Carmelite Saints Teresa of Avila and John of the Cross. Of course, these two Saints were responsible for founding a spin-off order the Discalced Carmelites. She also found many other problems with the editor’s quotations of the Gospels and other sections of the Bible.
The bishop assigned the review of the book to the Censor Librorum of the diocese to determine whether it was suitable for Catholic teaching. Based on the review of the book, the Censor determined the material was not consistent with Catholic teaching and should not be used by the Carmelite community in the Bismarck Diocese.
The Bismarck Carmelite community then asked Carmelite Province in Darien, IL if there was an alternative to the use of the book and they were told there was no alternative that the book was required. As the result of this decision, the Bishop of the Bismarck diocese disbanded the Carmelite community.
Affiliation and History of the New Ways Ministries
Editor of Climbing the Mountain as well as the Carmelite Province of the Most Pure Heart of Mary have endorsed the New Ways Ministries document entitled “A Home for All.” This document suggests that catholic teaching is oppressive to the LGBTQ+ people and suggests Catholic sexual ethics should be subordinated to the Church’s social justice goals.
The New Ways Ministries has had a very troubled history with the Catholic Church. It has been prohibited from speaking on behalf of the church. Here are some excerpts from Wikipedia.
- In 1984 Cardinal James Hickey barred the organization (New Ways Ministries) from the Archdiocese of Washington because of its dissent from traditional Catholic teaching on the issue of homosexuality, which condemns sexual activity between people of the same gender.
- That year, the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, then under the leadership of Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger (Later Pope Benedict the XVI), condemned the organization’s positions on homosexuality . . . .
- In 2010, Cardinal Francis George, Archbishop of Chicago and President of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB), stated New Ways did not present an authentic view of Catholic teaching
- In March 2011, the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops affirmed George’s statement and reiterated “…that in no manner is the position proposed by New Ways Ministry in conformity with Catholic teaching and in no manner is this organization authorized to speak on behalf of the Catholic Church or to identify itself as a Catholic organization.”
Both the editor and the Darien Province endorsed the New Ways Ministries document entitled “A Home for All” that states:
- We must affirm that Catholic teaching should not be used to further oppress LGBTQ people by denying rights rooted in their inherent human dignity and in the church’s call for social equality.
- “Should the Church’s sexual ethics tradition or its social justice tradition be the primary lens with which to examine LGBTQ equality initiatives? We believe it is imperative for Catholics and their leaders `to rely on the social justice tradition,” and disregard the sex involved in the LGBTQ activity is “Sodomy.”
In addition, to endorsing this document both the Darien Province and the editor have contributed funds to the Ministries. Every member in the Carmelite communities under the Darien Province is contributing to the New Ways Ministries whether they know it or not.
Reaction of My Governing Council
After the research was completed, my first step was to provide the information I had obtained to the director of our community. After she had reviewed the material, she then talked with the Carmelite District Director (Coordinator) who subsequently called the Province in Darien IL. He was given the same response that the Carmelite community in North Dakota was given. There is no alternative to this book, and it must be used.
I then asked the community director if I would be able to make a presentation to the council regarding the information I had obtained. On the evening prior to the meeting, she e-mailed all the attachments that I had provided to her regarding my research so that the council members would have the opportunity to read them before the meeting the next day.
After the business agenda had been completed, I was given the opportunity to go through my talking points for the other members of the council to understand what I had discovered.
The talking points provoked some very intense discussion regarding the facts themselves as well as my motivation for presenting them. During the comments there were accusations alleging that I wanted to hurt the community. It was also suggested that I did not like the LGBTQ community and that was the reason I was objecting to the book.
Regarding not providing the information to the community members. Many of the council members suggested that: the information that I provided were: 1) just opinions from various individuals, and 2) the information would induce stress and uncertainty among the various members of the community.
The council decided to vote on the issue of whether the information should be provided to the community. On a vote of 6 to 1 the council decided the information would NOT be provided to the community: however, all community members currently using the book, and all future individuals who would use the book would be advised that the book is not approved by the Catholic Church, but it is and excellent recap of Carmelite history.
My Response to the Council’s Action
The next general meeting of the Carmelite community occurred on the Saturday following the council meeting. Although the district director as well as our local community director were present at the meeting the issues I had raised were not addressed.
As part of the meeting there is an opportunity for the secretary to make a report or to talk to the community. At that point I, as Secretary, made the following statement, “Today will be my last day with the community. My discernment has come to an end, and I have decided not to become fully professed. I will submit my resignation to the council via e-mail later today.”
Of course, that announcement shocked many members of the community because I had been one of the most active members in setting up and preparing both the food and the room for the meetings as well as cleaning up after they were completed. These activities were in addition to my secretarial duties.
At the end of the meeting many individuals came to me and asked why I had taken such a drastic step. I advised them that I would provide them my reasons later.
The meeting adjourned a little after noon I immediately went home and drafted a resignation e-mail and sent it to the council indicating that my resignation was effective immediately.
A little later, I sent an e-mail to every member of the community that recapped my research findings, including the talking points that I had used during my presentation to the council, as well as all the actual attachments of my research.
I advised them I was choosing to give the information to them because the council had made the decision NOT to provide it to them. I told them this information was necessary because my pastor had told me their souls were in danger if they continued with this book and community – given the issues I had found in the research.
My email blast to all community members provoked considerable concern, consternation, and response from several members of the community including a demand to have a special meeting to address the issues. However, district and local leadership decided they will wait until the general meeting in next month to address the issues.
Conclusion
As indicated previously, I have made my decision regarding participation in this program. I am still awaiting responses from the Diocese of Phoenix and the Diocese of Bismarck. While this information that I have requested from these two dioceses may not be dispositive in terms of my individual actions, the information may help the individual members of my community make decisions about their own participation in the Lay Carmelite program.
The moral of this story is – Just because an organization appears to be a legitimate Catholic activity, you must research it thoroughly to ensure it is complying with all the requirements of the Church before you invest your time, money, and most importantly your soul in what you are about to join or undertake. Remember,
- There is a certain organizational inertia to continue to do things that are comfortable even though facts may demonstrate a change is required,
- Loyalty and cohesion of the group many times sustains that inertia, and
- In this case, that inertia can put souls in danger.
