Pope Francis and the “Clericalized Laity”: a Confused Critique

Pope Francis has issued an attack on American Catholics, denouncing them as “backwards” and  “reactionary” in an interview released Monday. Francis has made similar comments against his perceived “conservative” critics on other occasions. This particular denunciation received much more press coverage not because it was nastier (Francis last summer accused traditionalists of having a “dead faith”), but because of his specification that the Catholics he is targeting are Americans.

This embroiled Francis– who has spent a total of six days in the U.S. as pope– directly in U.S. political debates. His comments will likely embolden anti-Catholic forces in the U.S. who seek to denigrate Catholics who stand up for the Church’s teachings– “see, even the Pope disagrees with you.”

Francis has now extended his criticism of the “clericalism” of traditional priests to the “clericalism” of the laity, stating “the clericalized laity are frightening” and clericalism is “worse when it creeps into the laity.” But Francis has a confused conception of the “the clericalized laity” that is completely different from how this term had been used previously.

Pope John Paul II warned of “clericalizing the laity” in these terms: involvement “by the laity becomes a form of clericalism when the sacramental or liturgical roles that belong to the priest are assumed by the lay faithful, or when the latter set out to accomplish tasks of pastoral governing that properly belong to the priest.”  That is, “[t]he commitment of lay persons is politicized when the laity is absorbed by the exercise of ‘power’ within the Church . . . That happens when the Church is not seen in terms of the mystery of grace that characterizes her, but rather in sociological or even political terms.”

Francis, by contrast, has no qualms about casting the Church in political, sociological or worldly terms– indeed, he does it repeatedly in this very interview. Nor does he have any special problem with the laity taking on liturgical roles. Instead, Francis defines the “clericalization of the laity” as “living one’s own calling in an elitist way, wrapped up in one’s own group and erecting walls against the outside, developing possessive bonds with regard to roles in the community, cultivating arrogant and boastful attitudes towards others,” or else engaging in “complaining, negativity and chronic dissatisfaction with what is wrong.”

Continue reading at Rorate Caeli